Investigation Concludes Bystander Acted Lawfully in Deputy Rescue Shooting

Following a thorough review of the evidence, the State Attorney’s Office in Lee County ruled that Ashad Russell’s use of deadly force was legally justified. In its statement, the office wrote that Russell was “justified in using deadly force when he reasonably believed that the use of such force was necessary to prevent imminent death or great bodily harm to Deputy Dean Bardes or to prevent the imminent commission of a forcible felony upon Deputy Bardes. Our agency review is closed and no further action shall be taken by this office based upon the facts presented by this investigation and the applicable law.”

The decision effectively ends the legal inquiry into the case, confirming that Russell’s intervention was within Florida’s lawful parameters for the defense of others. Under state law, individuals are permitted to use deadly force if they believe such action is necessary to prevent serious injury or death to themselves or another person.

Deputy Bardes, a veteran of the Lee County Sheriff’s Office, survived the attack and later expressed gratitude for Russell’s actions, which likely saved his life. Sheriff Mike Scott also emphasized that Russell’s response exemplified civic courage and the importance of community members stepping in when lives are at risk.

However, the case was not without controversy. The family of Edward Strother voiced strong objections to the decision. Strother’s brother, Louis, questioned the narrative that framed Russell as a hero. “They are calling him a good Samaritan?” he said. “Was my brother armed?”

While investigators confirmed that Strother was unarmed during the confrontation, officials determined that his assault on a law enforcement officer constituted a life-threatening situation that warranted immediate defensive action.

The fatal encounter has continued to fuel public discussion about when armed civilians should intervene in violent incidents and the potential consequences of doing so. In this instance, prosecutors concluded that Russell’s quick decision prevented further harm and aligned fully with Florida’s self-defense statutes.

The case now stands closed, with officials reiterating that no further action will be taken.